Our baggage, unearthed: On trans remembrance, queer migration, and the unfinished work of belonging

By Asya Gündüz
Board Chair at CBRC

I am sitting outside one of the Canada Border Services Agency’s soulless buildings, waiting to learn whether a queer friend and community member will be deported the next day.

When the good news comes, relief arrives with it. Then an awkward silence settles between us. What now? We begin talking about the paperwork and uncertainty that remain after his pre-removal risk assessment, or PRRA. Afterwards, I learn he has not eaten for three days. Anxiety has taken up that much room in his body.

We share the news with six other community members still waiting for their own PRRA decisions. There is happiness, and we make room for it.

Before I have fully absorbed that relief, I receive a call from a trans woman refugee claimant who arrived from Türkiye only a week earlier. She is homeless. I am trying to help her find somewhere safe to sleep but a central intake referral does not, by itself, answer the question of where an undocumented trans woman can safely spend the night. Toronto’s October 2026 Directive now requires most bedded programs reserved for Canadians, only to send refugees to one centre away from their communities.

Then a message arrives from Türkiye. There have been more arrests targeting LGBTQIA+ activists. Some of my friends are in jail. The fear reaches across the distance immediately, carrying particular worries for our trans communities.

I feel caught between emergencies, trying to choose where to place my attention. What is expected of a community organizer whose belonging has been scattered across borders? How do you decide whose crisis gets the next hour of your life?

My baggage feels as though it cannot hold another thing. I remember to check my breathing.

And then I remember more than the emergencies. I remember the years of queer and trans organizing in Türkiye, the joy we made together and the possibilities we fought to open after the Gezi Park Protests. I remember the people we have lost, the work left unfinished, the lives interrupted. Those memories help me breathe, too. They remind me that the work we continue as queer migrants in Canada has a history, and that we have each other within it.

This is where I want to begin this Trans Awareness Week and Trans Day of Remembrance. With the intimate, exhausting relationship between remembering, surviving, and trying to belong.

The baggage I carry contains ghosts of memories and the afterlives of unfinished efforts. Some of it travelled with me. Some of it has accumulated here. Yet migration comes with an expectation that arrival should be a happy ending: leave the past where it happened, be grateful, begin again.

Sara Ahmed’s writing about the “melancholic migrant” helps name that pressure. She examines how migrants who keep speaking about racism can be treated as people unwilling to let go of injury, as though their remembering were the obstacle to belonging.[1]

I recognize something in that demand. How much of ourselves are we expected to bury to make our presence easier to welcome? Our memories contain knowledge about how to survive and how to organize. They also hold relationships that continue to matter, however far away the people we love may be. I look at the sky. Much like the ocean, “the time now is small, mobile, portable I, light blue,” much like feeling elsewhere, within here.[2]

Meanwhile, new weight keeps being added to our baggage...

The public conversation about immigration has shifted sharply. In 2022, 27% of Canadians told Environics Research that the country had too much immigration. That rose to 58% in 2024, before falling to 48% in 2026. The recent easing matters. So does the distance from where we stood four years ago.[3]

For those of us supporting people whose futures depend on being allowed to stay, the question of who is welcome is painfully close. We hear debates about numbers while trying to help someone eat, sleep, or get through the next appointment.

Bill C-12 became law in March 2026. Its new timing rules exclude some asylum claims from referral to the Immigration and Refugee Board, including certain claims made more than a year after first entry into Canada. People affected retain access to a PRRA, which is currently assumed to have a 30% approval rate. During the legislative process, Rainbow Refugee warned that trauma and fear can delay LGBTQIA+ people’s claims, including the time needed to disclose an identity safely.[4][5] These restrictions follow the 2023 expansion of the Safe Third Country Agreement across the Canada–US land border, widening restrictions on asylum claims by people arriving through the United States.[6]

The struggle for stability also runs through the TS2023 Initiative’s advocacy for people who benefited from Canada’s temporary measures following the earthquakes in Türkiye and Syria. A petition presented to Parliament in October 2026 calls for a further 36 months of temporary status and, where applicable, open work authorization. It is a request for more time to rebuild lives already disrupted.[7][8]

These are different circumstances and different legal pathways. What connects them, for me, is the demand that people keep rebuilding while the ground beneath their lives remains uncertain.

We encounter the health consequences of that uncertainty in our community work. Research has recorded some of the distance between arrival and access. In CBRC’s Our Health 2022 survey, nearly one in five newcomer respondents reported receiving no primary health care anywhere during the pandemic.[9]

In the 2019 Trans PULSE Canada survey, 38% of trans and non-binary newcomer respondents lacked a primary health care provider, compared with 19% of Canadian-born respondents. These community surveys describe the experiences of those who took part. They give us a glimpse of people trying to build a life without reliable access to care.[10]

These gaps also matter for HIV prevention. A 2025 study involving gay, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men in Toronto, Montreal, and Vancouver found that newcomers were less likely to have a primary care provider. This gap was, in turn, associated with lower use of STBBI testing and PrEP, medication used to prevent HIV. Precarious immigration status helped explain the unequal access to primary care.[11]

For me, these findings make it harder to treat immigration, housing, and HIV prevention as separate concerns. The person trying to arrange a health appointment is the same person trying to find a safe bed or understand whether they can remain in the country. Our services divide these needs into categories. A person has to live through them together.

Research matters. It can make institutional failures harder to dismiss, and help communities demand accountability. But those of us doing this work also know the exhaustion of explaining the same harms again, hoping that this account, this finding, this testimony will finally move someone to act.

I keep returning to the questions underneath my work: How can our communities’ struggles become a shared responsibility? How can the possible deportation of someone you have never met become a reason for you to act?

Trans Day of Remembrance asks us to honour people whose lives have been taken by anti-trans violence. I want that remembrance to reach into the conditions in which people are living now. I want the person searching for shelter tonight to matter with the urgency we bring to a name spoken at a vigil.

Within queer and trans health movements, this means taking migrant justice seriously as part of our work. It means building lasting relationships with migrant-led groups, paying for their knowledge, and giving them authority over decisions that affect their communities. It means supporting access to legal help and safe housing alongside health care, and challenging policies that make people’s lives more precarious.

It also means looking closely at our own organizations. Who is invited to tell a painful story, and who gets to decide what happens next? If lived experience matters to us, that commitment should be visible in our budgets and in who holds power. This is exactly the kind of leadership I hope to spearhead on CBRC’s Board.

The empathy I am asking for should change something. It should make someone willing to question an exclusion, accompany a neighbour, or commit resources after the emotional force of a story has passed. Community organizers need that commitment, too. We cannot keep making up for the absence of support with whatever remains of our own energy.

I still do not have a neat answer for how we expand this responsibility across communities in Canada. I am writing from inside that uncertainty. But I know that asking the people already carrying the most to become endlessly better at carrying it cannot be our plan.

I think again of the silence outside the CBSA building, after the good news. I want us to be able to stay in that relief a little longer. I want a future in which the next phone call does not require someone to become an entire support system on their own.

There is much in my baggage I want to keep and carry together. Our memories deserve a place in the futures we are trying to build. The joy we made together, and the people who made it possible, belong there.

This Trans Day of Remembrance, let us unearth the histories and losses we were asked to bury, and burn the expectation that we must carry their weight alone.

To the memory of Werde, Hande Kader, and Antar.

About the author

Photo credit: Jackie Brown

Asya Gündüz (she/her) is a community organizer and a policy leader. She chairs CBRC’s Board of Directors and is co-founder and chair of LubunTO, a Toronto-based community organization supporting LGBTQIA+ immigrants from different regions. She is the Lead, Trans Health Initiatives at the Ontario HIV Treatment Network and a doctoral candidate in Gender, Feminist and Women’s Studies at York University. Her work connects trans health, migrant justice, and community-led change.

Follow LubunTO on Instagram (@lubun.to) for community updates, events and advocacy, and explore LubunTO’s resources.

CBRC newcomer resources

Explore the research and resources below to learn more about queer and trans newcomer health and CBRC’s work with im/migrant and refugee communities.

Our Health: Newcomer LGBTQQIA+ people in Canada. Read the community report discussed in this article, including findings on access to primary health care during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Improving Care for Sexual and Gender Diverse Im/migrants and Refugees Living with HIV. Learn about this national study on experiences of HIV testing, care, and wellbeing, and see information for community members interested in participating. A companion page for service providers and community workers describes their role in the same study.

Population-Specific Resources. Visit the Immigrants section of CBRC’s resource directory for links to mental health and settlement resources from other organizations.

Sources and research notes

1. Ahmed, S. (2008). The Politics of Good Feeling. ACRAWSA e-journal, 4(1). ↩

Ahmed critiques the demand that migrants stop speaking about racism and move on from its injuries.

2. Trinh T. Minh-ha. (2011). Elsewhere, Within Here: Immigration, Refugeeism and the Boundary Event. Routledge, p. 1. ↩

Quoted from page 1, “Foreignness and the New Color of Fear.” The linked book preview includes the passage.

3. Environics Institute and Toronto Metropolitan University. (2026). Public Opinion on Immigration and Refugees. ↩

The telephone survey included 2,000 Canadian adults, interviewed September 8 to 21, 2026. The measure concerns immigration levels, not a direct measure of prejudice.

4. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada. (2026). New immigration and asylum measures from Bill C-12, the Strengthening Canada’s Immigration System and Borders Act, have become law. ↩

Royal assent March 26, 2026. Rules apply to claims from June 3, 2025. The one-year bar concerns first entry after June 24, 2020. A separate bar concerns claims after 14 days following crossings between Canada–US land ports. PRRA remains available.

5. Rainbow Refugee Society. (2025). Submission to the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration on Bill C-12. ↩

Submitted November 8, 2025. The warning about trauma, fear and safe identity disclosure appears on page 2.

6. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada. Canada–US Safe Third Country Agreement. ↩

The expansion took effect March 25, 2023. Exceptions and exemptions exist. The agreement does not apply to US citizens or stateless habitual US residents.

7. House of Commons. (2026). Petition 451-01325: Citizenship and immigration. ↩

Presented October 27, 2026. Requests a further 36 months of temporary status and applicable open work authorization for people covered by the earthquake measures. This is an advocacy request.

8. TS2023 Initiative. (2026). Announcement of the parliamentary petition for a 36-month extension. ↩

The Initiative describes its involvement and the petition’s use of its community survey and report.

9. Community-Based Research Centre. (2024). Our Health COVID-19 Community Report: Newcomer LGBTQQIA+ people in Canada. ↩

Our Health 2022 included 107 participants classified as newcomers using immigration status. Of 85 answering the primary-care question, 15 (18%) received no primary care anywhere. Table 3, page 12. This is not a representative population estimate or a trans-only sample.

10. Trans PULSE Canada. (2021). Health and Well-Being among Trans and Non-Binary Immigrants and Newcomers. ↩

2019 survey. The comparison groups include 92 newcomers and 2,488 Canadian-born participants. Newcomers arrived within five years. Primary-care comparison: Table 4, page 7. Non-random community sample.

11. Palma and colleagues. (2025). Disparities in healthcare, STI testing, and PrEP access among newcomer sexual minority men in Canada’s three largest urban centers. ↩

Engage data, 2017 to 2019. The study found small indirect associations through primary-care access, not a significant overall difference in PrEP use by immigration category. Findings cannot be generalized to trans women or all newcomers.

Disponible en français.

CBRC

About CBRC

Community-Based Research Centre (CBRC) promotes the health of people of diverse sexualities and genders through research and intervention development.
Our baggage, unearthed: On trans remembrance, queer migration, and the unfinished work of belonging
Our baggage, unearthed: On trans remembrance, queer migration, and the unfinished work of belonging
Check out Community-Based Research Centre. I just joined.